Two Approaches, One Science
Both the Public Health Approach and the Navigator Approach are grounded in the same radon science. The primary difference is not the science itself, but how that science is applied. The Public Health Approach begins with the population and works toward the household. Navigator begins with the household and works outward from the family's specific circumstances, exposures, and priorities.
| Public Health Approach | Navigator Approach |
|---|---|
| Begins with population-level risk management. | Begins with the individual household and family. |
| Designed to provide guidance that can be broadly applied across large populations. | Designed to help families evaluate their own circumstances and priorities. |
| Focuses on reducing risk across the greatest number of people. | Focuses on understanding actual household exposure and its relevance to the people who live there. |
| Uses standardized action levels and recommendations. | Uses action levels as one factor among many when evaluating risk and options. |
| Emphasizes consistency and simplicity in public messaging. | Emphasizes context, nuance, and individual decision-making. |
| Answers the question: "What recommendation is appropriate for most people?" |
Answers the question: "What does this result mean for my family?" |
| Well suited for public agencies, broad educational efforts, and population-wide risk communication. | Well suited for families seeking a deeper understanding before making a radon decision. |
| Often emphasizes what action should be taken. | Emphasizes understanding the science before deciding what action to take. |
| Success is measured by population-wide risk reduction. | Success is measured by helping families make informed decisions aligned with their circumstances. |
| Provides general guidance applicable to most homes. | Provides perspective tailored to the realities of a specific home and household. |